An older couple at a kitchen table reviewing printed pages together, with a calculator and coffee mugs beside them
Retirement Income

Withdrawal Rates and the 4% Rule in a Long Retirement

November 17, 2026South Jersey8 min read

The 4% rule is a research finding, not a rule. It describes the highest starting withdrawal that survived the worst historical 30-year periods in one study's data,1 it assumes a fixed withdrawal raised each year for inflation, and it says nothing about a retirement longer than 30 years. More recent research put the starting rate for someone retiring in 2026 at 3.9% under fixed-spending assumptions, and higher for households willing to adjust spending.2 The more useful exercise is testing your own plan against a long horizon, a poor first few years, and a spending rule you would actually follow.

Where the 4% rule came from

The figure traces to research published in 1994 that looked back through historical market returns and asked a narrow question: what is the highest percentage a retiree could withdraw in the first year, then raise each year for inflation, without running out of money over 30 years in any historical period studied?1 The answer clustered around 4%.

That is a useful finding. It is also a specific one. It described the worst historical case for a particular portfolio mix over a particular horizon, and most periods in the data would have supported more. It was never designed as a forecast, and it was never a promise about any individual's future.

Repetition turned it into a rule. Treated as a starting point for a conversation, it is reasonable. Treated as a plan, it skips most of what a plan has to decide.

What it assumes, and what that leaves out

AssumptionWhat it leaves out
A 30-year horizonRetirements that run longer, which is common for couples and for anyone retiring early
A fixed withdrawal, raised for inflation every yearThe fact that most households adjust spending when markets fall
A single balanced portfolioPensions, Social Security, and other income that change how much the portfolio has to do
Historical returns as the testA future that does not have to resemble the past
No taxes or feesThe difference between a gross withdrawal and what reaches your checking account

The first row matters most here. A plan that works for 30 years and fails in year 32 has not failed early by any reasonable standard, but for a 62-year-old couple year 32 is well within the range they need to plan for. Why the horizon has to run longer than average life expectancy is covered in Longevity Risk in a Retirement Income Plan.

What more recent research says

Morningstar's research on retirement income for 2026 put the highest safe starting withdrawal rate at 3.9% for a 30-year retirement under fixed, inflation-adjusted spending.2 The same research found that retirees willing to use flexible spending approaches could start meaningfully higher.

Two points keep a figure like this in proportion. It moves from year to year with expected returns on stocks and bonds, which is why it is described as a figure for retirees starting in a particular year. And it rests on its own assumptions about success rates and portfolio mix, so it is a reference point rather than a number to adopt.

The direction of the finding is more durable than the figure. Longer horizons and fixed spending point to lower starting rates. Shorter horizons and flexible spending point to higher ones.

This is not investment advice. No withdrawal rate in this article is a recommendation, and no rate assures that assets will last for any particular period. What is appropriate depends on your own income, assets, health, and spending. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

How a plan gets tested instead

A rule of thumb gives one number. A test asks how a specific plan behaves across many possible futures.

Historical testing runs the plan through actual past sequences of returns, including the worst ones. It shows how the plan would have held up in periods that really happened.

Monte Carlo analysis runs the plan through thousands of simulated return sequences and reports the share in which money lasted to the chosen age. A result of 85% means the plan lasted in 85% of simulations, not that there is an 85% chance of anything in particular. The output is only as good as the return and inflation assumptions put into it.

Whichever method is used, three inputs decide most of the answer: the horizon, which should run past average life expectancy; the order of returns in the first several years, which matters more than the average; and the spending rule. Why early losses do more damage once withdrawals begin is covered in How Investment Management Changes at Retirement.

Fixed spending versus flexible spending

The 4% rule assumes a household keeps raising its withdrawal for inflation through every market decline. Few do. Most trim discretionary spending in a bad year, and plans that build that in can usually support a higher starting withdrawal.

Guardrail approaches are the common way to formalize it. Spending starts at a chosen rate, and if the withdrawal rises above an upper boundary as a share of the portfolio, spending is cut by a set amount. If it falls below a lower boundary after strong markets, spending can rise. The cost is variability: some years' spending is lower than planned.

The useful test is whether you would actually follow the rule. A flexible plan that relies on cuts nobody would make is a fixed plan with an optimistic label. Separating essential spending from discretionary spending, so the flexible part is clearly identified, is covered in What Retirement Income Planning Actually Is.

Income that does not depend on the portfolio changes all of this. Social Security is adjusted for inflation and continues for life, and delaying a claim increases it permanently, which reduces how much the portfolio has to supply in the longest retirements. For a married couple that decision runs through the surviving spouse, covered in Social Security Claiming and the Survivor Decision.

Deferred income for the far end

Some households address the longest outcomes directly, by setting aside part of their savings to buy income that begins late in life. A qualifying longevity annuity contract is one version of this, bought with money from a traditional IRA or an employer plan.3

The mechanics are specific. The amount used is excluded from required minimum distribution calculations until income begins, and income must begin by the first day of the month after age 85. Roth IRAs cannot be used. A lifetime dollar limit applies, indexed and published by the IRS each year, and the older limit based on a percentage of the account balance was removed by legislation in 2022.3

The trade-offs are just as specific. The money is generally not available once committed, payments may not keep pace with inflation unless the contract provides for it, and the income depends on the insurer that issues it. Whether any of that suits a household depends on what else funds its spending and what it gives up in liquidity.

Annuities and other insurance products are offered through Maisch Financial Group, LLC, and our insurance representatives may receive commissions on them. That is a conflict of interest, disclosed in our Form ADV. Any guarantee is backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuing carrier and is governed entirely by the contract. Nothing here recommends a product.

Planning in Pilesgrove

Pilesgrove is the Salem County township along Route 40 known for the Cowtown Rodeo and the Cowtown Farmers Market, and in a farming community it is not unusual for land or a family property to sit alongside the retirement accounts. That changes the withdrawal question, because a portfolio that is only part of the household's wealth may not need to carry the whole retirement, and a 4% figure built for a portfolio that does can point the wrong way. A retirement planner in NJ is useful here less for a number than for testing one against the household's own income, horizon, and spending. Our retirement income planning, investment management, tax planning, health care and Medicare planning, and estate and legacy planning are delivered as one coordinated engagement, so a withdrawal rule, a claiming decision, and a tax year are weighed against the same plan. Pilesgrove is within reach of our Mount Laurel office, and we also meet by phone or video. The communities we serve are listed on our cities served page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the 4% rule?

It is a finding from research published in 1994: in the historical data studied, a retiree who withdrew 4% of the portfolio in the first year and raised that amount each year for inflation would not have run out of money over any 30-year period. It describes the worst historical case for a particular portfolio and horizon. It is not a forecast or a promise.

Is the 4% rule still safe?

It depends on the horizon, the spending rule, and expected returns. Morningstar's research for 2026 put the highest safe starting rate at 3.9% for a 30-year retirement under fixed, inflation-adjusted spending, and found that flexible spending approaches could support higher starting rates. The figure moves from year to year and no rate assures that assets will last for a particular period.

What withdrawal rate should I use for a retirement longer than 30 years?

There is no single number. Under fixed spending, longer horizons point to lower starting rates than the 30-year figures usually quoted. The more useful approach is to test your own plan against a horizon past average life expectancy, a poor sequence of early returns, and the spending rule you would actually follow, taking into account Social Security, any pension, and taxes.

What are guardrails in retirement withdrawals?

Guardrails are a flexible spending rule. Spending starts at a chosen rate; if the withdrawal rises above an upper boundary as a share of the portfolio, spending is cut by a set amount, and if it falls below a lower boundary after strong markets, spending can rise. The trade-off for a potentially higher starting rate is that some years' spending is lower than planned.

What is a qualifying longevity annuity contract?

It is a deferred income annuity bought with traditional IRA or employer plan money that begins paying late in life. The amount used is excluded from required minimum distribution calculations until income starts, which must be by the first day of the month after age 85. Roth IRAs cannot be used, a lifetime dollar limit applies that the IRS publishes each year, and the money is generally not available once committed.

Key takeaways

  • The 4% rule describes the worst historical case in one study, not a promise about the future.
  • It assumes 30 years and fixed inflation-adjusted spending; longer retirements and real spending behavior change the answer.
  • More recent research put the 2026 starting rate at 3.9% under fixed spending, and higher with flexible spending.
  • Test a plan against a long horizon, a poor early sequence, and a spending rule you would actually follow.
  • Income that does not depend on the portfolio, such as Social Security, reduces what the portfolio has to supply.

Sources

  1. William P. Bengen, "Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data," Journal of Financial Planning, October 1994. financialplanningassociation.org Back
  2. Morningstar, The State of Retirement Income for 2026 (December 2025), on safe starting withdrawal rates for a 30-year retirement under fixed and flexible spending. morningstar.com Back
  3. U.S. Department of the Treasury regulations on qualifying longevity annuity contracts; SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022, Public Law 117-328, Section 202; and IRS guidance publishing the annual dollar limit. irs.gov Back

The withdrawal rate cited is a research estimate for retirees starting in a particular year and rests on that research's own assumptions; it is not a recommendation. The annual dollar limit for qualifying longevity annuity contracts is indexed and is not quoted here. Confirm current figures with the source or your tax professional.

Let's Work Together

Test your plan, not the rule.

If you want to see how your own withdrawal plan behaves against a longer horizon and a difficult first few years, we are happy to go through it with you.

About Services Articles Events Client Login
Schedule a Conversation

By Andrew Maisch, CFF® & Christian Maisch

Related reading: Retirement Income Planning.