Three kinds of provider manage retirement money, and they differ less in what they invest in than in the standard they owe you, how they are paid, and how much of your situation they see. A registered investment adviser owes a fiduciary duty on its advisory services.1 A broker-dealer representative making a recommendation works under Regulation Best Interest.2 A robo-advisor is usually a registered adviser itself, but its advice is built from a questionnaire and covers the accounts on its platform.3 Which fits depends mostly on how many decisions your retirement has to coordinate.
Three ways retirement money gets managed
Most people meet these three models in a different order than the one that would help them choose. A workplace plan introduces a broker or a call center, a phone app introduces a robo-advisor, and a neighbor introduces an advisory firm. Each looks like a version of the same thing. They are not.
Provider
Standard owed
Usually paid by
Usually sees
Registered investment adviser
Fiduciary duty of care and loyalty on advisory services
Advisory fees: a percentage of assets, a flat fee, or hourly
Anything from one portfolio to the whole household plan, depending on the engagement
Broker-dealer representative
Regulation Best Interest when a recommendation is made
Commissions or other transaction-based pay
The product or transaction being recommended
Robo-advisor
Usually a fiduciary as a registered adviser, within the limits of its service
A platform fee, usually a percentage of assets
The answers to its questionnaire and the accounts on its platform
The last column is the one that matters most in retirement. While you are saving, a narrow view costs little, because every account has the same job. Once withdrawals begin, the accounts stop being interchangeable: which one funds next year's spending, how that interacts with Social Security timing and a pension, and what it does to the tax bracket all depend on seeing the whole picture at once.
Which standard applies, and when
A fiduciary duty is an ongoing obligation of care and loyalty owed across an advisory relationship. It requires advice in your best interest based on a reasonable understanding of your situation, and it requires conflicts of interest to be eliminated or disclosed fully enough for you to give informed consent.
Regulation Best Interest applies at the moment a broker-dealer recommends a security or an investment strategy. It also requires acting in your best interest and carries disclosure, care, and conflict obligations. The practical difference is timing: unless a broker agrees to monitor your account, the obligation attaches to the recommendation rather than continuing through the relationship.
Neither standard promises a good outcome, and neither makes every recommendation correct. What they change is what the person advising you is obliged to consider and disclose. The detail of what a fiduciary duty does and does not cover is in What Fiduciary Duty Requires, and What It Does Not.
One person, more than one standard
The three categories are cleaner on paper than in practice. Many individuals are registered in more than one capacity, or work for a firm with an affiliated broker-dealer or insurance agency. The standard that applies then depends on which capacity a particular recommendation is made in, and a title such as financial advisor does not tell you which.
That is why asking whether someone is a fiduciary produces less useful answers than asking which of their services carry the duty. The second question forces a service-by-service answer.
We apply the same test to ourselves. Maisch Financial Group is fee-based. Investment advisory services are offered through Maisch Financial Partners, LLC, a New Jersey state registered investment adviser. Insurance services are offered through Maisch Financial Group, LLC, and our insurance representatives may receive commissions on insurance products. That is a conflict of interest, it is disclosed in our Form ADV, and the full structure is set out at the end of this article. How every compensation model creates its own conflicts is covered in Conflicts of Interest in Financial Advice.
This is not investment advice. Nothing here recommends a particular provider, firm, or account type, and no category of provider is better for everyone. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Review your own situation with a qualified professional.
How each is paid
How a provider is paid shapes what it is pulled toward recommending, so compare the model before the price.
Fee model
How it works
What to ask
Percentage of assets
An annual fee calculated on the assets the firm manages
What is the rate in annual dollars on my balance, and what does it include?
Flat fee or retainer
A set price for planning or ongoing service
What is included, and what triggers additional charges?
Hourly or project
A price for a defined piece of work
Who implements the plan once it is delivered?
Commission
Paid when a product is bought or a transaction occurs
What do you earn on this recommendation, and from whom?
Platform fee
A percentage of assets for an automated service
What access to a human advisor comes with it, and at what cost?
Every provider in this article can be checked in a few minutes without contacting it first.
Search the firm and the individual. The SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site at adviserinfo.sec.gov covers registered advisers, and FINRA BrokerCheck at brokercheck.finra.org covers brokers. Both show registration and any disclosed disciplinary history.
Read Form CRS. Firms serving retail investors must provide a short relationship summary describing their services, fees, conflicts, and standard of conduct, including suggested questions to ask.4
Read Form ADV Part 2A. The firm brochure describes fees in Item 5, other financial industry activities and affiliations in Item 10, and client referrals and other compensation in Item 14. Part 2B covers the background of the individual who would advise you.
Question
A specific answer sounds like
A vague answer sounds like
Which of your services carry a fiduciary duty?
Each service named, with the standard that applies to it, in writing
We always put clients first
What will I pay in a normal year?
A dollar figure that includes fund and platform costs
A percentage only, or it is built in
What shapes my portfolio?
Cash flow needs, other accounts, the pension, the tax picture, the horizon
Your risk score
Who handles income, tax, estate, and health care decisions?
Named people and how their work connects
We focus on investments
What triggers a review between meetings?
Specific events, such as a retirement date or a health change
Call us anytime
A provider that only manages investments can still answer the fourth question honestly. The answer is simply that you will be coordinating the rest yourself, which is worth knowing before you start.
Matching the provider to your stage
The right model tends to change as retirement approaches, because the number of interacting decisions rises sharply around the date you stop working.
Still saving, several years out. With savings in one or two accounts and no withdrawals planned, a low-cost automated service or a simple model can be a reasonable fit. The decisions are mostly about contribution levels and allocation.
Within about five years of retiring. This is where the picture usually widens: claiming age, a pension election, Roth conversion windows, and the first withdrawal order all have to be settled, and several are hard to reverse. Coordinated planning earns its cost here if it is going to anywhere. The decisions that belong in each of those years are covered in Retiring in Five Years Near Cherry Hill.
Drawing income. Once withdrawals are under way, the questions become ongoing ones: which account funds next year, how required distributions interact with the tax bracket, and how health care costs are covered. If a pension and Social Security cover essential spending and the portfolio is a reserve, a simpler arrangement may still be enough.
Later retirement and legacy. Beneficiary designations, titling, extended care, and simplifying accounts for whoever may need to step in come to the front. Some of that is investment work and much of it is not.
Planning in Swedesboro
Swedesboro is the small Gloucester County borough on Raccoon Creek that takes its name from its early Swedish settlers, and many of the pre-retirees we meet there arrive with accounts gathered from several employers and at least one app. Sorting out which provider is responsible for which account is often the first useful conversation, before any question about investments. Anyone looking for a financial advisor in NJ will meet all three models described here, and the standard each one owes is the clearest way to tell them apart. Our investment management, retirement income planning, tax planning, estate and legacy planning, and health care and Medicare planning are delivered as one coordinated engagement, so the accounts are considered together rather than one platform at a time. Swedesboro is a short drive from our Mount Laurel office, and we also meet by phone or video. The communities we serve are listed on our cities served page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a financial advisor, a broker, and a robo-advisor?
They differ mainly in the standard they owe you, how they are paid, and how much of your situation they see. A registered investment adviser owes a fiduciary duty on its advisory services and is usually paid advisory fees. A broker-dealer representative making a recommendation works under Regulation Best Interest and is often paid by commission. A robo-advisor is usually a registered adviser itself, charges a platform fee, and builds its advice from a questionnaire covering the accounts on its platform.
Is a robo-advisor a fiduciary?
Most robo-advisors are registered investment advisers and owe a fiduciary duty, but within the limits of the service they provide. Their advice is generated from a questionnaire and usually covers only the accounts held on the platform, so it may not account for a pension, Social Security timing, outside accounts, or a multi-year tax picture unless the service includes access to a human planner.
How do I check whether an advisor is registered?
Search the firm and the individual on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site at adviserinfo.sec.gov and on FINRA BrokerCheck at brokercheck.finra.org. Then read the firm's Form CRS relationship summary and its Form ADV Part 2A brochure, where Item 5 covers fees, Item 10 covers affiliations, and Item 14 covers referral and other compensation.
Can one person act as both an advisor and a broker?
Yes. Many individuals are registered in more than one capacity or work for firms with affiliated broker-dealers or insurance agencies. The standard that applies then depends on the capacity in which a particular recommendation is made, which is why it is more useful to ask which services carry a fiduciary duty than to ask whether someone is a fiduciary.
When does a robo-advisor make sense in retirement?
Usually when the picture is simple: savings in one or two accounts, no withdrawals yet, or a pension and Social Security that already cover essential spending so the portfolio acts as a reserve. As withdrawals begin and claiming, tax, and account-sequencing decisions start to interact, a service limited to the accounts on its platform covers less of what has to be decided.
Key takeaways
The three models differ most in the standard owed, how they are paid, and how much of your situation they see.
Ask which services carry a fiduciary duty, not whether someone is a fiduciary.
Robo-advisors are usually registered advisers, but their advice covers the accounts on the platform.
Compare the total cost in annual dollars, including fund costs outside the advisory fee.
The case for coordinated planning grows sharply in the five years around the retirement date.
Sources
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers (2019). sec.govBack
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Regulation Best Interest: The Broker-Dealer Standard of Conduct. sec.govBack
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Division of Investment Management, Guidance Update No. 2017-02, Robo-Advisers. sec.govBack
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Form CRS Relationship Summary and Form ADV Part 2 requirements; investor guidance at Investor.gov. investor.govBack
This article contains no usage statistics, fee benchmarks, or performance figures. Survey data on how many households use each type of provider varies widely by who was asked and who published it, and published fee ranges date quickly. Ask any firm for its own fee schedule in writing and in annual dollars.
The questions in this article work on any firm, including this one. If you want to know which of your accounts is getting which kind of advice, we are happy to go through it with you.
Maisch Financial Group, LLC and its affiliate Maisch Financial Partners, LLC (together, "Maisch Financial," "we," "us," or "our") respect your privacy. This Privacy Policy explains how we collect, use, share, and protect information when you visit maischfinancial.com (the "Site"), contact us through it, or register for one of our events. By using the Site, you agree to the practices described here.
Scope of This Policy
This Privacy Policy applies to information gathered through the Site and related online communications. If you become a client, the nonpublic personal information you provide in connection with our advisory or insurance services is also governed by our Privacy Notice, which we deliver to clients as required by federal securities regulations. Where the two documents differ, the Privacy Notice controls for client information. A copy of the Privacy Notice is available at any time on request.
Information We Collect
Information you give us. When you call us, email us, complete a contact or scheduling request, or register for a workshop, we may collect your name, email address, telephone number, mailing address, the event you are attending, and anything you choose to include in your message.
Information collected automatically. When you visit the Site, our hosting and analytics providers may automatically record technical information such as your IP address, browser type, device type, operating system, referring website, the pages you view, and the date and time of your visit. This information is gathered through cookies, server logs, and similar technologies.
Please do not send sensitive information through the Site. Do not submit Social Security numbers, account numbers, passwords, or other sensitive financial information through website forms, social media, or unencrypted email. If we need this information to serve you, we will arrange a secure way to receive it.
How We Use Information
We use the information we collect to respond to your questions and requests, schedule conversations and appointments, register you for events and send related reminders, send educational content you have asked to receive, operate, maintain, and improve the Site, protect the security and integrity of the Site, and meet our legal, regulatory, and recordkeeping obligations.
How We Share Information
We do not sell your personal information, and we do not share it with nonaffiliated third parties for their own marketing purposes. We share information only in the following circumstances:
Affiliated entities. Investment advisory services are offered through Maisch Financial Partners, LLC, and insurance services are offered through Maisch Financial Group, LLC. Information you provide may be shared between these affiliated entities so that we can respond to your request.
Service providers. We use trusted vendors to host the Site, manage scheduling, deliver email, and measure Site traffic. These providers may access information only as needed to perform services for us and are expected to protect it.
Legal and regulatory requirements. As a registered investment adviser, we are subject to examination by securities regulators. We may disclose information to regulators, auditors, or law enforcement, or in response to a subpoena, court order, or other legal process, and to protect our rights, our clients, or the security of the Site.
Business transfers. If our firm is involved in a merger, acquisition, succession, or sale of assets, information may be transferred as part of that transaction, subject to this Policy.
With your consent. We may share information for any other purpose with your permission.
Cookies and Analytics
The Site uses cookies and similar technologies to keep it working properly and to understand how visitors use it. You can set your browser to refuse or delete cookies; some parts of the Site may not function as intended if you do. The Site does not currently respond to browser "Do Not Track" signals.
Third-Party Websites and Services
The Site contains links to websites and services we do not control, including our client portal provider, social media platforms such as Facebook and LinkedIn, and government resources. Their collection and use of information is governed by their own privacy policies, and we are not responsible for their content or practices. We encourage you to review those policies before providing any information.
Electronic Communications and Recordkeeping
Securities regulations require us to retain certain business communications. Emails, messages, and other communications you send to us, including through the Site or our social media pages, may be retained, reviewed, and produced to regulators as part of our books and records. By using the Site or providing information to us, you agree that we may communicate with you electronically about security, privacy, and administrative matters related to your use of the Site.
How We Protect Information
We maintain administrative, technical, and physical safeguards designed to protect the information under our control. Although we make good faith efforts to maintain the security of that information, no method of transmission over the internet or of electronic storage is completely secure. We cannot guarantee that information will remain free from unauthorized access, use, disclosure, or alteration, and we assume no liability to you or any other party for unauthorized access to information you provide through the Site.
If we become aware of a security breach affecting your information, we will notify you as required by applicable law and may do so electronically so that you can take appropriate protective steps. If you believe there has been a breach of the Site's security, please contact us at 856.203.6911.
How Long We Keep Information
We keep information for as long as needed for the purposes described in this Policy and for as long as required by applicable law, including the recordkeeping rules that apply to investment advisers and insurance agencies.
Your Choices
You may unsubscribe from our educational or marketing emails at any time by using the link in any such email or by contacting us. Transactional, regulatory, and service messages may continue if you are a client. You may also ask us to update or correct the contact information we hold about you, or ask what information we have collected through the Site, by contacting us using the details below. We will respond as required by applicable law.
Children's Privacy
The Site is intended for adults and is not directed to children. We do not knowingly collect personal information from anyone under the age of 18. If you believe a child has provided information to us through the Site, please contact us and we will delete it.
No Offer or Advisory Relationship
Using the Site, submitting a form, or sending us a message does not create an advisory or client relationship. Nothing on the Site is an offer to buy or sell any security or insurance product. An advisory relationship begins only after you sign a written agreement with Maisch Financial Partners, LLC and receive its Form ADV disclosure brochure.
Updates to This Privacy Policy
We may update or amend this Privacy Policy at any time. Updates are effective when posted, and the effective date above will change to reflect them. We encourage you to review this Policy periodically. Your continued use of the Site after an update constitutes your acceptance of the revised Policy.
Contacting Us
If you have questions about this Privacy Policy or would like a copy of our client Privacy Notice, please contact us: